Insurance Discussion Forum

Insurance Discussion Forum

Did You Know?

Q:

Who has the most affordable homeowners insurance?

I’m looking for the most affordable homeowners insurance policy that still provides strong coverage. Can you compare the total annual cost for policies from different insurers and explain how pricing varies based on factors like coverage limits (dwelling, personal property, liability), deductibles, discounts (multi-policy, security system, claims-free), and location? Also, please outline what is included and excluded in the cheapest options, and how customer satisfaction and claim-handling reputation affect value for the price.

Home Insurance

All Replies

Viewing 4 reply threads

  • For me, the biggest thing was what was actually included vs. excluded. The cheapest quote I got didn’t cover a lot of water damage scenarios I care about, so it wasn’t actually worth the savings. I eventually went with a slightly pricier policy that covered dwelling, personal property, and a good liability limit, plus bundling saved me some money. A friend who went with the absolute cheapest policy ended up frustrated because their claim took forever and they had gaps in coverage they didn’t realize.

  • No joke, I got fed up and just asked my neighbor who has been in the house 20+ years which company they use. Turned out their insurer was cheaper and covered more than the big names I was quoting online, just because they’ve been with them so long and have no claims. If you’re ok with higher deductibles, prices drop big time. But if you need lower deductibles or extra coverage like contents replacement, expect to pay more no matter who you choose.

  • Homeowners insurance quotes feel like dating apps – you think you found a good match with a cheap price until you read the fine print and suddenly it’s “no coverage for this” and “unless you pay extra for that.” 😂 I ended up picking a middle‑priced policy that covered everything I actually care about (water backup, decent liability) instead of the super cheap one that sounded great until I read the exclusions list. Definitely ask about discounts — multi‑policy and security system discounts helped a lot.

  • Yes you are Right Merry Joe, I’m so confused by homeowners insurance. 😂 I got one quote that was like $700/year and another from a different company that was $2,000/year — same house, same coverage limits, just different insurer. I didn’t realize how much deductible size, location, and whether you bundle with car insurance changes the price. I still don’t know which is really “better” because the cheap one looked good on paper, but I’ve heard cheap policies sometimes skim on actual claims.

  • Honestly, “most affordable” really depends on your exact address and house details. I compared quotes from State Farm, GEICO, Progressive, and Erie last year and Erie was the cheapest for my home — but the coverage limits were lower, so I had to bump them up to feel comfortable. In my case the dwelling and personal property limits were key; I saved money by increasing the deductible and bundling my auto insurance. I also got discounts for an alarm system and claims‑free history. But one friend chose State Farm even though it was a bit more expensive because he trusts their claims folks more.

Viewing 4 reply threads

  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.
New to Communities?

New to Communities?

Ask a Question